New Listing

511 tabby lane

Key West, FL 33040

$1,800,000

3 BEDS 1 BATH
1,368 SQFT0.1 AC LOT
Residential - Single Family
New Listing
Image 1: Lot View
Image 2: Lot View
Image 3: Backyard
Image 4: Backyard
Bedrooms 3
Total Baths 1
Full Baths 1
Square Feet 1368
Acreage 0.1
Status Active
MLS # 620880
County Monroe
More Info
Category Residential - Single Family
Status Active
Square Feet 1368
Acreage 0.1
MLS # 620880
County Monroe
Steeped in Key West history and unlike anything else available in Old Town, 511 Tabby Lane presents an opportunity to own one of the island's most extraordinary properties. Hidden away at the end of a charming pedestrian lane with direct access to iconic Duval Street, this remarkably private home offers a level of seclusion and potential that is virtually impossible to replicate.Rich in character and history, the property sits on an exceptionally deep 4,200-square-foot lot, a rarity in Old Town. There is simply no other property currently available that offers this combination of privacy, location, and land. The expansive lot provides endless possibilities, with ample space for a pool, pool house, guest quarters, lush gardens, outdoor entertaining areas, and more while still preserving the home's unique Old Town charm.Completely hidden from view behind a gated entrance, the property feels like a private tropical sanctuary in the heart of Key West. Whether you envision thoughtfully restoring the existing residence or creating a one-of-a-kind island compound, the possibilities are exceptional. The structure is believed to be a non-contributing building with HARC (buyer to verify), offering additional flexibility for future improvements.Adding to its rarity, the property is zoned for Transient License Receivership (buyer to verify), making it an incredibly attractive opportunity for investors, developers, or anyone seeking a truly unique Old Town residence.Properties of this caliber and significance rarely become available. 511 Tabby Lane represents a chance to own a piece of Key West history while creating something that future generations will treasure. This is Old Town at its most authentic--and an opportunity that simply cannot be duplicated.
Location not available
Listing
Street
Satellite

Exterior Features

  • Style Single Family
  • Construction Single Family
  • Siding Frame
  • Exterior Fruit Tree(s), Privacy Wall/Fence
  • Garage No
  • Water Buyer to Verify
  • Sewer Buyer to Verify
  • Lot Dimensions 40 X 105

Interior Features

  • Appliances Refrigerator, Oven
  • Living Area 1,368 SQFT
  • Year Built 1913

Financial Information

  • Parcel ID 1016144
  • Zoning HRCC(1 - 4) - Hist Res Comm Core 1-4 SF Specl

Additional Services

Internet Service Providers

Listing Information

Listing Provided Courtesy of Island Home Realty Inc.
Listing Agent Paige Bethel
Florida Keys, MLS
Listing data is current as of 08/09/2026.

Contact Our Agent

By clicking “Submit,” I agree to be contacted by Lake Homes Realty, LLC, its affiliates, and real estate professionals via call, text, and email for real estate services. This includes by automated means, even if your number is on a federal, state, or our internal Do Not Call list. To opt out, you can reply "stop" at any time or reply "help" for assistance. You can also click the unsubscribe link in the emails. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency may vary. You also agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.